1/22/2024 0 Comments Store betty boopThe action was brought to trial before Hon. Issue was joined by the service of the defendants' answers on or about June 14, 1932. The action was commenced by the service of the summons and complaint on the defendants on or about April 30, 1932. It was later noticed when Kane lost her lawsuit, that though Betty Boop bore a strong resemblance, Kane did not originate the scat-singing or baby-voice and was unable to prove any of her claims in court. Kane admitting to these several women originating the baby-voice before her, ruled out the baby singing style. Bernier and her husband Milton Watson (who was also discovered by Ash), were also in the same "Paul Ash" Chicago revue as Baby Esther Jones in 1926. Bernier was known as "The Girl With The Baby Voice" and was discovered by Paul Ash in 1926, several years before Kane was discovered by Ash, and Bernier was best known for her baby voice. However she admitted during the lawsuit, that Duncan Sisters, Irene Franklin, Frances White, Nan Halperin and Peggy Bernier were all prominent before her, and that each and every one of these Caucasian female singers had preceded her by singing using the baby-voice technique and the baby-doll style. When questioned, Kane did not admit to stealing anyone's "Boop". So Kane could not lay claim to the copyright of Betty's name, because Helen Kane was known as Sugar Kane on the Broadway stage, not Helen Boop. The court ruled out "Betty Boop's" name as infringement, because Helen Kane was not known as Helen Boop. Fleischer Studios and Paramount Pictures have stolen the idea I put across, and I am not going to stand for it! Betty Boop is nothing more or less than a caricature of me and not so much of a caricature at that." She was cited as saying: "While imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, this type of imitation is the opposite. Helen Kane claimed that her reason for suing was not about money and that she felt that they had stolen her identity. $250,000 Infringement Lawsuit: Baby Esther Jones.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |